Second Story Realty Logo

828 Nicholas Street
Henderson, NC 27536

$74,999

Not in a Subdivision – Henderson Township – Vance County

828 Nicholas Street
Henderson, NC 27536

$74,999

  • A white house with a front porch and columns is partly hidden by overgrown bushes and trees. The yard has uneven grass, and a stone walkway leads to the porch steps.
  • A small white house with a dark roof is partly obscured by overgrown trees and grass in the front yard. The sky is cloudy, and the house appears to need maintenance.
  • A white house with a front porch and columns is partly hidden by overgrown bushes and trees. The yard has uneven grass, and a stone walkway leads to the porch steps.
  • A small white house with a dark roof is partly obscured by overgrown trees and grass in the front yard. The sky is cloudy, and the house appears to need maintenance.
Save
Save

Single Family

Active

Not in a Subdivision

Henderson Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 1.5
  • Square Feet: 1498
  • Acres: 0.15
  • Year Built: 1916

Single Family

Active

Save

Not in a Subdivision

Henderson Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 1.5
  • Square Feet: 1498
  • Acres: 0.15
  • Year Built: 1916

3
Bed

1.5
Bath

1498
sqft

0.15
acres

Save

  • 🛠️ Rehab/Investment Opportunity

  • ❄️ Central Heating And Air

  • 📐 Almost 1500 Square Footage

Rehab/Investment Opportunity in the city limits of Henderson, Vance County. 3 Bedrooms with the possibility of 4th. Rare Central Heating and Air for a home of this age in this area.

House across the street renting for $1200. Bring this home back to life. Almost 1500 square footage so plenty of space. Contact agent today for private showing.

Rehab/Investment Opportunity in the city limits of Henderson, Vance County. 3 Bedrooms with the possibility of 4th. Rare Central Heating and Air for a home of this age in this area. House across the street renting for $1200. Bring this home back to life. Almost 1500 square footage so plenty of space. Contact agent today for private showing.

Maps

Listing History

Date

Status

Price

  • 2026-06-21

    Active

    $74,999

Documents

Documents Source: Doorify MLS IDX Feed

  • A white house with a front porch and columns is partly hidden by overgrown bushes and trees. The yard has uneven grass, and a stone walkway leads to the porch steps.
  • A small white house with a dark roof is partly obscured by overgrown trees and grass in the front yard. The sky is cloudy, and the house appears to need maintenance.

Nearby Listings

Statuses
Date Range
Price

828 Nicholas Street

$74,999

1498

Not in a Subdivision

$50

3

1916

0.15

Listed on
Jun 21st 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

306 Chavasse Avenue

$149,900

1176

Not in a Subdivision

$127

3

1948

Sold on
Dec 23rd 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

332 Chavasse Avenue

$154,000

1306

Not in a Subdivision

$118

3

1950

0.3

Listed on
Jan 22nd 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

845 S William Street

$189,000

3483

Not in a Subdivision

$54

4

1912

1.18

Listed on
Jun 12th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

994 Maple Street

$142,000

891

Not in a Subdivision

$159

2

1954

0.14

Listed on
Apr 30th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

275 Gholson Avenue

$319,000

3380

Not in a Subdivision

$94

5

1945

1.12

Sold on
Nov 25th 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

828 Nicholas Street

$74,999

Doorify IDX Logo

306 Chavasse Avenue

$149,900

Doorify IDX Logo

332 Chavasse Avenue

$154,000

Doorify IDX Logo

845 S William Street

$189,000

Doorify IDX Logo

994 Maple Street

$142,000

Doorify IDX Logo

275 Gholson Avenue

$319,000

Doorify IDX Logo
Listings Nearby to Listing
6 nearby listings found

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

Compared to Similar Homes that Recently Sold….

828 Nicholas Street has a Price per Square Foot of $50.

Here’s how that compares to the surrounding area:

63% below the Henderson Township median ($136)

64% below the City of Henderson median ($140)

64% below the Vance County median ($140)

  • A small gray house at 505 Harriett Street in Henderson has boarded-up windows and a closed door, sitting on bare, uneven ground. An air conditioning unit is installed below one window, with trees and grass visible in the background.
    505 Harriett Street, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $40,100
    • $34 Price per Sqft
    • 1,182 Sqft
    • 0.11 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-10-31
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $34,899 less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (316 sq ft smaller)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬇️ ($16 lower)

    • Condition: ⚖️ (Both are restoration projects)

    This property on Harriett Street is a very direct comparison to 828 Nicholas Street as both were sold as restoration opportunities in need of significant work. Even though this sold listing was smaller, it sold for a much lower price per square foot, even after adjusting for the size difference. This suggests that the current asking price for 828 Nicholas Street might be positioned a bit high for the local investor market when compared to similar project homes.

    🔴 Based on this similar project sale, 828 Nicholas Street appears to be priced at a premium for its current condition.

  • A single-story house at 306 Chavasse Avenue in Henderson features light gray siding, a small covered front porch, blue steps, and white trim. A few shrubs and plants accent the grassy yard, with a wooden fence in the background.
    306 Chavasse Avenue, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $149,900
    • $127 Price per Sqft
    • 1,176 Sqft
    • Acres
    • Sold on 2025-12-23
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬆️ (Sold for $74,901 more)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (322 sq ft smaller)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($77 higher)

    • Condition: ⬆️ (Fully renovated vs. rehab project)

    This sold listing represents a finished product, featuring a bright, open floor plan and modern updates that 828 Nicholas Street currently lacks. While the home for sale offers more square footage, it requires a significant investment to reach the move-in ready state seen in this property. The price gap between the two reflects the substantial value of a turn-key home compared to a property positioned as a rehab opportunity.

    🟡 If you are looking for a project, 828 Nicholas Street offers more space, but this sold home demonstrates the premium buyers are willing to pay for a finished, move-in ready residence.

  • A single-story white house with dark roof, red shutters, and a brick chimney. The front has a small porch, steps, and bushes, with a screened-in side porch. The yard is bare, with trees and a driveway visible.
    125 E Jennette Avenue, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $165,000
    • $111 Price per Sqft
    • 1,490 Sqft
    • 0.53 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-03-18
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬆️ (Sold for $90,001 more)

    • Sq Ft: ⚖️ (Similar size)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($61 higher)

    • Condition: ⬆️ (Maintained/habitable vs. rehab project)

    Comparing 828 Nicholas Street to this property on E Jennette Avenue highlights the difference between a habitable, maintained home and a full restoration project. This sold listing features classic hardwood floors and a functional layout, whereas the home for sale is described as an investment opportunity needing to be brought back to life. The higher price for this property is justified by its usable condition and the larger half-acre lot it sits on.

    🟡 828 Nicholas Street is priced for an investor, while this property was ready for an owner-occupant, explaining the significant price difference for similar square footage.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the “why” behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

20 Minute Strategy Call-a – Schedule a meeting

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.

828 Nicholas Street
Henderson, NC 27536

828 Nicholas Street
Henderson, NC 27536

$74,999

$74,999

Not in a Subdivision – Henderson Township – Vance County

828 Nicholas St

Henderson

3 br

1498 sqft

$74,999

TWP Henderson

CTY Vance

SUB Not in a Subdivision

Share to...
LinkedInRedditThreadsPinterestBlueskyNextdoorChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AI