This sold listing is a true ranch on two acres, which commands a premium for both the single-level living and the expansive lot. While 612 N Main Street has a charming 1.5-story layout, it lacks the garage and the elaborate outdoor entertaining space found at Jeffress Drive. The higher cost per square foot for the Jeffress home makes sense given the acreage and the finished basement suite.

This sold listing offers significantly more space and a larger lot for a higher total price, though its price per square foot is very similar to 612 N Main Street. While the home on John Street features a large carport and a gazebo, 612 N Main Street provides a more manageable footprint with a recently updated primary suite. Both properties share that classic mid-century charm with hardwood floors and traditional layouts.

Comparing 612 N Main Street to this property is a study in different tiers of historic preservation. The home on S Elm Street is a grand, fully restored Colonial Revival on over an acre and a half, justifying its much higher price point with high-end finishes and massive curb appeal. 612 N Main Street is a more modest, attainable option that offers the same downtown lifestyle without the luxury price tag.