Charming single-story tan house with black shutters, a small front porch, and a white door, set against a backdrop of tall trees and a grassy yard with a gravel path leading to the entrance. Conveniently located at 5586 Shelton Creek Road in Oxford, this inviting home offers both tranquility and easy access to local amenities.A single-story beige house with dark shutters sits surrounded by trees. A small porch with steps leads to the front door. The yard is grassy with a gravel driveway and a stone-lined walkway.Single-story beige house with a front porch, surrounded by tall trees and a gravel driveway, on a sunny day. The area around the trees has exposed soil and patches of grass.Single-story tan house with dark shutters, a gray roof, and a white front door. It sits on a grassy lawn surrounded by tall trees on a sunny day. Steps lead up to the entrance.Single-story house with beige siding and brick foundation, a wooden deck with stairs, and surrounded by trees. The yard has patches of bare red soil and grass.Single-story beige house with a brick foundation, wooden deck, and stairs, surrounded by grass and trees on a sunny day.A wooden deck with two blue plastic chairs overlooks a lush, green forest. Sunlight filters through the tall trees, casting shadows on the deck.A small pond surrounded by trees sits beside a gravel road under a clear blue sky. A green sign on the grass marks the pond’s location.Bright living room with wood floors, a blue floral rug, modern furniture, large window with outdoor view, ceiling fan, colorful artwork, and decorative accents like plants and lamps.

1 / 32

5586 Shelton Creek Road · Oxford, NC 27565

Oxford, NC 27565 · Shelton Hills
ActiveSingle FamilyShelton HillsWalnut Grove TownshipGranville County
$327,500
$198 / sq ftListed Jul 17, 2026
Save

Book a strategy call

Charming single-story tan house with black shutters, a small front porch, and a white door, set against a backdrop of tall trees and a grassy yard with a gravel path leading to the entrance. Conveniently located at 5586 Shelton Creek Road in Oxford, this inviting home offers both tranquility and easy access to local amenities.A single-story beige house with dark shutters sits surrounded by trees. A small porch with steps leads to the front door. The yard is grassy with a gravel driveway and a stone-lined walkway.Single-story beige house with a front porch, surrounded by tall trees and a gravel driveway, on a sunny day. The area around the trees has exposed soil and patches of grass.Single-story tan house with dark shutters, a gray roof, and a white front door. It sits on a grassy lawn surrounded by tall trees on a sunny day. Steps lead up to the entrance.Single-story house with beige siding and brick foundation, a wooden deck with stairs, and surrounded by trees. The yard has patches of bare red soil and grass.

4
Bedrooms

2
Bathrooms

1,658
Square feet

2.07
Acres

2019
Year built
Shelton HillsWalnut Grove TownshipGranville CountyMLS 10178741

5586 Shelton Creek RoadActive
$327,500 · 4 bd · 2 ba · 1,658 sf

Highlights

  • 90,169-Square-Foot Lot
  • Spacious Living Areas
  • Four Well-Appointed Bedrooms
  • Two Full Bathrooms

About this home

Welcome to this inviting 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom single-family home nestled in the desirable Shelton Hills community of Oxford, NC. Set on an impressive 90,169-square-foot lot, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and outdoor space.

Inside, you'll find a thoughtfully designed floor plan featuring spacious living areas and four well-appointed bedrooms, providing flexibility for a variety of lifestyles. The two full bathrooms add everyday convenience, while the home's layout is ideal for both relaxing and entertaining.

Step outside to enjoy the expansive lot, offering endless possibilities for outdoor recreation, gardening, future enhancements, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Whether you're looking for extra space to spread out or a place to create your own private retreat, this property delivers.

Located in the sought-after Shelton Hills neighborhood, this home offers the charm of country-style living while remaining conveniently close to shopping, dining, schools, and everything Oxford has to offer. Don't miss this exceptional opportunity to own a home with acreage, comfort, and potential in one of the area's most desirable communities. Listing Agent does not hold Earnest Money. Please submit all offers including PreApproval or POF to southeastteam@trelora.com

Location

Walnut Grove Township · Granville County · Oxford, NC

Property history

3 listings on Doorify MLS since 2025

  1. Price decreasedSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10178741$327,500−$2,500 · −0.8%$198/sqft
  2. Listed for saleSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10178741$330,000$199/sqft
  3. Coming soonSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10178741$330,000$199/sqft
  4. Listing RemovedSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10129260$275,000$168/sqft
  5. Price decreasedSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10129260$275,000−$25,000 · −8.3%$168/sqft
  6. Price decreasedSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10129260$300,000−$12,500 · −4.0%$184/sqft
  7. Price decreasedSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10129260$312,500−$7,500 · −2.3%$191/sqft
  8. Listed for saleSource: IDX Doorify MLS #10129260$320,000$196/sqft

Documents

1 floor plan

5586 Shelton Creek Road, Oxford, NC 27565 10178741 20260717184615808730000000(opens in a new tab)

Nearby listings

Near 5586 Shelton Creek Road · Oxford, NC 27565

Status

Statuses-buttons
  • All
  • Sold (1)
Living area

Living Area

Price

Price

Date range

Date Range
Listings Nearby to Listing

5586 Shelton Creek Road
Shelton Hills · This home
$327,500
1,658
$198
4
2019
2.07
Active
Jul 8, 2026

1507 Rainbow Circle
Shelton Hills
$329,900
2,123
$155
3
2002
1.24
Sold
Jul 23, 2026

1545 Dogwood Drive
Shelton Hills
$265,000
1,176
$225
3
1989
1.05
Sold

1551 Dogwood Drive
Shelton Hills
$320,000
1,344
$238
3
2001
1.52
Sold
Apr 9, 2026

1195 US 158
Not in a Subdivision
$532,500
1,904
$280
2
2003
4.39
Sold
Mar 25, 2026

5684 Rock Bottom Road
Walnut Grove
$269,900
1,850
$146
3
2006
2.46
Active
Sep 16, 2026

1 Nearby Listing
Search all homes

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

How the price compares

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

This home
$198
per sq ft
City of Oxford
$184
median · this home is 8% above
Walnut Grove Township
$200
median · this home is 1% below
Granville County
$200
median · this home is 1% below

Sold for
$308,000
Per sq ft
$197
Size
1,562 sq ft
Lot
1.39 acres

1524 Dogwood Drive

Sold Jan 31, 2025
Sold for $20k less96 sq ft smaller$1 lower per sq ftSimilar updates

This sold listing is a modular home, which typically carries a different market value than a stick-built home like 5586 Shelton Creek Road. While this property features nice updates like granite countertops and stainless appliances, the home for sale is over 20 years newer and sits on a larger 2-acre lot. The price difference between the two reflects the added value of newer, traditional construction and extra land.

Bottom line
Given that 5586 Shelton Creek Road is a newer stick-built home with more acreage, the price premium over this modular property is very reasonable.

Sold for
$265,000
Per sq ft
$225
Size
1,176 sq ft
Lot
1.05 acres

1545 Dogwood Drive

Sold Feb 18, 2026
Sold for $63k less482 sq ft smaller$27 higher per sq ftVisibly more dated

This property on Dogwood Drive is much smaller and older, featuring more dated elements like honey oak cabinets and a rustic wood exterior. In contrast, 5586 Shelton Creek Road offers a much more modern interior and significantly more living space. Even though this home sold for a lower total price, it was actually more expensive on a per-foot basis.

Bottom line
5586 Shelton Creek Road represents a much better value, offering a newer, larger home for a lower price per square foot.

Sold for
$320,000
Per sq ft
$238
Size
1,344 sq ft
Lot
1.52 acres

1551 Dogwood Drive

Sold Jun 12, 2026
Sold for $8k less314 sq ft smaller$40 higher per sq ftWell-maintained

This home sold for nearly the same price as the home for sale, despite being nearly 300 square feet smaller and built in 2001. While it is well-maintained with nice finishes, 5586 Shelton Creek Road provides significantly more square footage and the benefits of a home built in 2019. You are getting much more house for almost the same investment.

Bottom line
The home for sale is positioned very well, offering more space and a much newer build for a similar price point.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the “why” behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.