Second Story Realty Logo

4509 Cannady Mill Road
Oxford, NC 27565

$189,900

Not in a Subdivision – Fishing Creek Township – Granville County

4509 Cannady Mill Road
Oxford, NC 27565

$189,900

  • A single-story brick house at 4509 Cannady Mill Road in Oxford sits on a large, grassy yard with trees in the background and partly cloudy sky overhead. Shrubs line the front of the house, and a small porch is visible at the entrance.
  • Single-story brick house with black shutters, a front porch with metal railings, and stairs leading to the door. A manicured lawn, a small tree, and bushes are visible in front, with a partly cloudy sky overhead.
  • A room with large windows and draped curtains, a red and white faded carpet, a chandelier, a wooden front door, and a white wall with a door leading to another area. Sunlight brightens the space.
  • A small room with wood-paneled walls, a red carpet, a window with beige curtains and valance, a vintage chandelier, and an old-fashioned rotary phone mounted on the wall.
  • A dimly lit kitchen with dark wood cabinets, marble-patterned countertops, a double sink under a window with curtains, a black stove, black refrigerator, a striped rug, and dark tile flooring. A single ceiling light is on.
  • A single-story brick house at 4509 Cannady Mill Road in Oxford sits on a large, grassy yard with trees in the background and partly cloudy sky overhead. Shrubs line the front of the house, and a small porch is visible at the entrance.
  • Single-story brick house with black shutters, a front porch with metal railings, and stairs leading to the door. A manicured lawn, a small tree, and bushes are visible in front, with a partly cloudy sky overhead.
  • A room with large windows and draped curtains, a red and white faded carpet, a chandelier, a wooden front door, and a white wall with a door leading to another area. Sunlight brightens the space.
  • A small room with wood-paneled walls, a red carpet, a window with beige curtains and valance, a vintage chandelier, and an old-fashioned rotary phone mounted on the wall.
  • A dimly lit kitchen with dark wood cabinets, marble-patterned countertops, a double sink under a window with curtains, a black stove, black refrigerator, a striped rug, and dark tile flooring. A single ceiling light is on.
Save
Save

Single Family

Active

Not in a Subdivision

Fishing Creek Township

Granville County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Square Feet: 1734
  • Acres: 0.87
  • Year Built: 1974

Single Family

Active

Save

Not in a Subdivision

Fishing Creek Township

Granville County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Square Feet: 1734
  • Acres: 0.87
  • Year Built: 1974

3
Bed

2
Bath

1734
sqft

0.87
acres

Save

  • ๐Ÿš— Covered Carport

  • ๐Ÿงบ Interior Laundry Area

  • ๐Ÿงฑ Brick Construction

  • ๐Ÿชต Partially Finished Basement

  • โ˜€๏ธ Concrete Patio

  • ๐ŸŒณ Spacious Backyard

Opportunity awaits with this classic brick ranch full of potential! Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms on the main level, this home offers a solid foundation for buyers looking to add their own style and updates. The attached covered carport provides convenient parking and easy access to the home, while the interior laundry area adds everyday practicality.

Inside, you’ll find a cozy living room and dining area that create a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Downstairs, the partially finished basement offers additional flexible space that could be transformed into a recreation room, home office, workshop, or storage area.

Step outside to enjoy the concrete patio overlooking a spacious backyard with plenty of room for gardening, outdoor entertaining, or giving your furry friends space to roam and play. With its desirable brick construction, functional floor plan, and endless possibilities, this home is ready for someone with vision to bring it to life. Whether you’re looking for your next home or an investment opportunity, a little TLC could unlock tremendous value and make this property truly shine.

Opportunity awaits with this classic brick ranch full of potential! Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms on the main level, this home offers a solid foundation for buyers looking to add their own style and updates. The attached covered carport provides convenient parking and easy access to the home, while the interior laundry area adds everyday practicality. Inside, you’ll find a cozy living room and dining area that create a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Downstairs, the partially finished basement offers additional flexible space that could be transformed into a recreation room, home office, workshop, or storage area. Step outside to enjoy the concrete patio overlooking a spacious backyard with plenty of room for gardening, outdoor entertaining, or giving your furry friends space to roam and play. With its desirable brick construction, functional floor plan, and endless possibilities, this home is ready for someone with vision to bring it to life. Whether you’re looking for your next home or an investment opportunity, a little TLC could unlock tremendous value and make this property truly shine.

Maps

Listing History

Date

Status

Price

  • 2026-06-04

    Active

    $189,900

Documents

Documents Source: Doorify MLS IDX Feed

  • A single-story brick house at 4509 Cannady Mill Road in Oxford sits on a large, grassy yard with trees in the background and partly cloudy sky overhead. Shrubs line the front of the house, and a small porch is visible at the entrance.
  • Single-story brick house with black shutters, a front porch with metal railings, and stairs leading to the door. A manicured lawn, a small tree, and bushes are visible in front, with a partly cloudy sky overhead.
  • A room with large windows and draped curtains, a red and white faded carpet, a chandelier, a wooden front door, and a white wall with a door leading to another area. Sunlight brightens the space.
  • A small room with wood-paneled walls, a red carpet, a window with beige curtains and valance, a vintage chandelier, and an old-fashioned rotary phone mounted on the wall.
  • A dimly lit kitchen with dark wood cabinets, marble-patterned countertops, a double sink under a window with curtains, a black stove, black refrigerator, a striped rug, and dark tile flooring. A single ceiling light is on.

Nearby Listings

Statuses
Date Range
Price

4509 Cannady Mill Road

$189,900

1734

Not in a Subdivision

$110

3

1974

0.87

Listed on
Jun 3rd 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

4045 Joe Hamme Road

$374,900

2036

Not in a Subdivision

$184

3

1917

5

Sold on
Jun 2nd 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

4577 Hight Road

$390,000

1872

Not in a Subdivision

$208

3

1996

2.3

Sold on
Feb 16th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

4501 Gresham Drive

$530,000

2426

Gresham Crossing

$218

3

2015

0.92

Sold on
May 18th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

4509 Cannady Mill Road

$189,900

Doorify IDX Logo

4045 Joe Hamme Road

$374,900

Doorify IDX Logo

4577 Hight Road

$390,000

Doorify IDX Logo

4501 Gresham Drive

$530,000

Doorify IDX Logo
Listings Nearby to Listing
15 nearby listings found

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

Compared to Similar Homes that Recently Sold….

4509 Cannady Mill Road has a Price per Square Foot of $110.

Here’s how that compares to the surrounding area:

43% below the City of Oxford median ($192)

45% below the Granville County median ($201)

  • Charming single-story white house at 4577 Hight Road in Oxford, featuring a covered porch, attached carport, and a large front lawn beside tall pine trees under a blue sky with scattered clouds.
    4577 Hight Road, Oxford, NC 27565
    • Price: $390,000
    • $208 Price per Sqft
    • 1,872 Sqft
    • 2.3 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-02-16
    Full Listing

    • Price: โฌ†๏ธ (Sold for $200k more)

    • Sq Ft: โฌ†๏ธ (Slightly larger footprint)

    • Cost/SqFt: โฌ†๏ธ (Sold for $98 more per sq ft)

    • Condition: โš–๏ธ (Both have dated interior features)

    This property is a modular home on over 2 acres that sold for a significant premium despite having similar interior finishes to the home for sale. While this sold listing offers a pool and more land, 4509 Cannady Mill Road provides a much lower cost per square foot for a stick-built brick home. Both properties feature older cabinetry and flooring, but the price gap here is quite wide.

    ๐ŸŸข For a buyer looking to build equity through renovations, 4509 Cannady Mill Road appears to be a very strong opportunity compared to this sale.

  • A grassy backyard with scattered trees and a wooden structure on the right, bordered by a red fence, under a colorful sunset sky with pink, orange, and purple clouds.
    4045 Joe Hamme Road, Oxford, NC 27565
    • Price: $374,900
    • $184 Price per Sqft
    • 2,036 Sqft
    • 5 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-06-02
    Full Listing

    • Price: โฌ†๏ธ (Sold for $185k more)

    • Sq Ft: โฌ†๏ธ (About 300 sq ft larger)

    • Cost/SqFt: โฌ†๏ธ (Sold for $74 more per sq ft)

    • Condition: โฌ†๏ธ (Renovated farmhouse vs. needs TLC)

    This sold listing is a beautifully renovated 1917 farmhouse sitting on a generous 5-acre lot. While 4509 Cannady Mill Road is much more affordable, it lacks the modern kitchen updates and the extensive acreage found here. The price difference represents a clear trade-off between a move-in-ready homestead and a project home with great potential.

    ๐ŸŸก If you are looking for a classic rural lifestyle, 4509 Cannady Mill Road offers a similar vibe at a much lower entry price for those willing to do the work.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the โ€œwhyโ€ behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

20 Minute Strategy Call-a – Schedule a meeting

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumersโ€™ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.

A single-story brick house at 4509 Cannady Mill Road in Oxford sits on a large, grassy yard with trees in the background and partly cloudy sky overhead. Shrubs line the front of the house, and a small porch is visible at the entrance.

4509 Cannady Mill Road
Oxford, NC 27565

4509 Cannady Mill Road
Oxford, NC 27565

$189,900

$189,900

Not in a Subdivision – Fishing Creek Township – Granville County

A single-story brick house at 4509 Cannady Mill Road in Oxford sits on a large, grassy yard with trees in the background and partly cloudy sky overhead. Shrubs line the front of the house, and a small porch is visible at the entrance.

4509 Cannady Mill Rd

Oxford

3 br

1734 sqft

$189,900

TWP Fishing Creek

CTY Granville

SUB Not in a Subdivision

Share to...
LinkedInRedditThreadsPinterestBlueskyNextdoorChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AI