Second Story Realty Logo

2555 Nutbush Road
Henderson, NC 27537

$369,500

Not in a Subdivision – Middleburg Township – Vance County

2555 Nutbush Road
Henderson, NC 27537

$369,500

Save

Single Family

Active

Not in a Subdivision

Middleburg Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2.5
  • Square Feet: 2037.12
  • Acres: 1.08
  • Year Built: 1970

Single Family

Active

Not in a Subdivision

Middleburg Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2.5
  • Square Feet: 2037.12
  • Acres: 1.08
  • Year Built: 1970

4
Bed

2.5
Bath

2037.12
sqft

1.08
acres

  • ⛳ Kerr Lake Country Club Community

  • 🌳 Secluded 1.08 Acre Lot

  • 🔥 Brick Fire Place

  • 🪵 Wood Floors

  • 🚗 Oversized Two Car Garage

  • 💰 No City Taxes

A must see rare opportunity to own a Colonial brick home within the Kerr Lake Country Club community. If you enjoy lake & boat fun, fishing, lazy days on the water, or golf, this is the home for you.

This 4bd, 2.5bth vintage home sits on a beautiful secluded 1.08 acre lot. Renovations include NEW!! windows 2024, HVAC 2026, SS Fridge 2023 and dishwasher 2026, stovetop 2023, well water pump 2023, septic and leech lines serviced 2024, basement waterproofed with new drain & pump 2025, roof 2023, and new leaf guards on all gutters.

As you enter on the right, the brick fire place with new custom mantle gives the family room a warm rustic feel while the formal living space offers flexibility on the left. You’ll love the wood floors in great condition and plenty of windows fill the space with natural light.

Four bedroom is well maintained offering multi-generational family living. Oversized two car garage. No city taxes will keep a little money in your pocket. Come see Kerr Lake!!

A must see rare opportunity to own a Colonial brick home within the Kerr Lake Country Club community. If you enjoy lake & boat fun, fishing, lazy days on the water, or golf, this is the home for you. This 4bd, 2.5bth vintage home sits on a beautiful secluded 1.08 acre lot. Renovations include NEW!! windows 2024, HVAC 2026, SS Fridge 2023 and dishwasher 2026, stovetop 2023, well water pump 2023, septic and leech lines serviced 2024, basement waterproofed with new drain & pump 2025, roof 2023, and new leaf guards on all gutters. As you enter on the right, the brick fire place with new custom mantle gives the family room a warm rustic feel while the formal living space offers flexibility on the left. You’ll love the wood floors in great condition and plenty of windows fill the space with natural light. Four bedroom is well maintained offering multi-generational family living. Oversized two car garage. No city taxes will keep a little money in your pocket. Come see Kerr Lake!!

Listing History

Date

Status

Price

  • 2026-06-18

    Active

    $369,500

Nearby Listings

Statuses
Date Range
Price

2555 Nutbush Road

$369,500

2037.12

Not in a Subdivision

$181

4

1970

1.08

Listed on
Jun 18th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

2732 Nutbush Road

$339,999

3016

Not in a Subdivision

$113

3

1967

0.73

Listed on
Apr 13th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

75 Fairview Drive

$300,000

1544

Kerr Lake Country Club

$194

3

1987

0.43

Sold on
Apr 14th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

2856 Nutbush Road

$290,000

1484

Not in a Subdivision

$195

3

1990

0.84

Sold on
Sep 16th 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

2118 Nutbush Road

$200,000

1027

Not in a Subdivision

$195

2

1963

0.49

Sold on
Jun 16th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

1080 Hedrick Drive

$449,900

1977

Kerr Lake Country Club

$228

3

1990

0.86

Listed on
May 29th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

2555 Nutbush Road

$369,500

Doorify IDX Logo

2732 Nutbush Road

$339,999

Doorify IDX Logo

75 Fairview Drive

$300,000

Doorify IDX Logo

2856 Nutbush Road

$290,000

Doorify IDX Logo

2118 Nutbush Road

$200,000

Doorify IDX Logo

1080 Hedrick Drive

$449,900

Doorify IDX Logo
Listings Nearby to Listing
2 nearby listings found

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

Compared to Similar Homes that Recently Sold….

2555 Nutbush Road has a Price per Square Foot of $181.

Here’s how that compares to the surrounding area:

12% below the Middleburg Township median ($205)

31% above the City of Henderson median ($138)

31% above the Vance County median ($138)

  • Nestled at 101 Jeffress Drive in Henderson, this single-story brick house features a light brown roof and is surrounded by tall trees. The large garage on the left complements several front windows, while a well-maintained lawn and a few plants adorn the welcoming entrance.
    101 Jeffress Drive, Henderson, NC 27537
    • Price: $260,000
    • $166 Price per Sqft
    • 1,566 Sqft
    • 1.58 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-01-13
    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $109.5k less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (Smaller by 471 sq ft)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬇️ (Lower by $15/sqft)

    • Condition: ⬆️ (More modern interior updates)

    This sold listing on Jeffress Drive is a fantastic example of a fully updated brick ranch in the area. It features very modern flooring and a clean, neutral interior that feels a bit more current than the vintage vibe at 2555 Nutbush Road. Additionally, this home sits on over 1.5 acres, offering even more privacy than the home for sale. When you look at the price difference, this property provided a lot of value with its updated systems and larger lot for over $100,000 less than the current asking price of the home on Nutbush Road.

    🔴 With its modern updates and larger lot, this sold listing suggests that 2555 Nutbush Road is currently priced above the recent market trend for updated brick homes.

  • A single-story house with beige siding, dark shutters, and a red roof sits on a well-kept lawn at 2856 Nutbush Road, Henderson. Bushes line the front and trees fill the background, with a small outbuilding visible on the left.
    2856 Nutbush Road, Henderson, NC 27537
    • Price: $290,000
    • $195 Price per Sqft
    • 1,484 Sqft
    • 0.84 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-09-16
    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $79.5k less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (Smaller by 553 sq ft)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ (Higher by $14/sqft)

    • Condition: ⬇️ (Slightly more dated kitchen)

    Located just down the street, this sold listing provides a direct comparison for the neighborhood. This home is a single-story ranch, which typically commands a higher price per foot than two-story homes like 2555 Nutbush Road. While this property features some dated interior elements like honey oak cabinets and popcorn ceilings, it sold at a price point that makes the current asking price for the home for sale look a bit high. Even though 2555 Nutbush Road is larger and has a brick exterior, the jump in total price is significant for the area.

    🔴 Given that this nearby ranch sold for much less, the home for sale may be priced at the top of the local market.

  • A two-story house with three dormer windows and a front porch sits on a grassy lawn, surrounded by tall green trees and shrubs under a blue sky.
    75 Fairview Drive, Henderson, NC 27537
    • Price: $300,000
    • $194 Price per Sqft
    • 1,544 Sqft
    • 0.43 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-04-14
    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $69.5k less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (Smaller by 493 sq ft)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ (Higher by $13/sqft)

    • Condition: ⚖️ (Both have significant updates)

    This sold listing on Fairview Drive offers a great look at the value of location, as it sits directly on the golf course. While 2555 Nutbush Road is a larger home with more acreage, this property sold for a higher price per square foot because of its premium lot and updated primary bathroom. Both homes have seen major mechanical updates recently, including new roofs and HVAC systems, which is a huge plus for any buyer. The home for sale provides more interior living space and a larger, more secluded lot, which balances out the golf course frontage found here.

    🟡 The price for 2555 Nutbush Road appears fairly positioned when you consider the extra square footage and land you are getting compared to this golf course property.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the “why” behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.

Elegant two-story brick home at 2555 Nutbush Road, Henderson, featuring black shutters, a central front door with an American flag, neatly trimmed bushes, a curved driveway, lush green lawn, and tall trees in the background.

2555 Nutbush Road
Henderson, NC 27537

2555 Nutbush Road
Henderson, NC 27537

$369,500

$369,500

Not in a Subdivision – Middleburg Township – Vance County

Elegant two-story brick home at 2555 Nutbush Road, Henderson, featuring black shutters, a central front door with an American flag, neatly trimmed bushes, a curved driveway, lush green lawn, and tall trees in the background.

2555 Nutbush Rd

Henderson

4 br

2037 sqft

TWP Middleburg

CTY Vance

SUB Not in a Subdivision

Share to...