Second Story Realty Logo

1820 S Garnett Street Extension
Henderson, NC 27536

$158,900

Not in a Subdivision – Henderson Township – Vance County

1820 S Garnett Street Extension
Henderson, NC 27536

$158,900

  • A single-story brick house with a gray roof sits among tall trees on a spacious, shaded yard at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension in Henderson. The home features a small covered front porch and several windows.
  • Empty living room with light blue walls, two windows with white valances, hardwood floor, a white front door, and a glass storm door. Sunlight streams in and white curtains hang by one window.
  • A mostly empty living room with light blue walls, white trim, hardwood floors, a window with a valance, a white front door, and an open doorway leading to a wood-paneled kitchen.
  • Empty room with light blue walls, hardwood floor, a wooden door, and a white fireplace with a red-tiled hearth. An open doorway reveals part of a bathroom in the background.
  • A single-story brick house with a gray roof sits among tall trees on a spacious, shaded yard at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension in Henderson. The home features a small covered front porch and several windows.
  • Empty living room with light blue walls, two windows with white valances, hardwood floor, a white front door, and a glass storm door. Sunlight streams in and white curtains hang by one window.
  • A mostly empty living room with light blue walls, white trim, hardwood floors, a window with a valance, a white front door, and an open doorway leading to a wood-paneled kitchen.
  • Empty room with light blue walls, hardwood floor, a wooden door, and a white fireplace with a red-tiled hearth. An open doorway reveals part of a bathroom in the background.
Save
Save

Single Family

Active

Not in a Subdivision

Henderson Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Square Feet: 1435
  • Acres: 0.31
  • Year Built: 1959

Single Family

Active

Save

Not in a Subdivision

Henderson Township

Vance County

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Square Feet: 1435
  • Acres: 0.31
  • Year Built: 1959

3
Bed

2
Bath

1435
sqft

0.31
acres

Save

  • 🪵 Authentic Hardwood Flooring

  • 🌲 Cozy Pine Paneling

  • 🚪 Classic Pine Cabinets

  • 🌳 Fully Fenced Backyard

Charming 1959 Classic with Endless Potential! Discover this mid-century gem featuring timeless character and solid bones, perfectly situated in a highly desirable Henderson location.

Inside, you will find authentic hardwood flooring and cozy pine paneling that bring warmth and nostalgia to the living spaces, complemented by classic pine cabinets in the kitchen. The property boasts a spacious, fully fenced backyard–ideal for pets, gardening, or outdoor gatherings.

Being located within the city limits, you will enjoy all town amenities while being just moments away from local grocery stores, pharmacies, shopping, and dining. Commuting is a breeze with quick, central access to both US-1 and I-85.

This home has wonderful character and is being sold strictly AS-IS. It is the perfect canvas for an investor or a buyer looking to invest some TLC and updates to make it shine. Bring your vision and restore this classic beauty to its full potential!

Charming 1959 Classic with Endless Potential! Discover this mid-century gem featuring timeless character and solid bones, perfectly situated in a highly desirable Henderson location. Inside, you will find authentic hardwood flooring and cozy pine paneling that bring warmth and nostalgia to the living spaces, complemented by classic pine cabinets in the kitchen. The property boasts a spacious, fully fenced backyard–ideal for pets, gardening, or outdoor gatherings. Being located within the city limits, you will enjoy all town amenities while being just moments away from local grocery stores, pharmacies, shopping, and dining. Commuting is a breeze with quick, central access to both US-1 and I-85. This home has wonderful character and is being sold strictly AS-IS. It is the perfect canvas for an investor or a buyer looking to invest some TLC and updates to make it shine. Bring your vision and restore this classic beauty to its full potential!

Maps

Listing History

Date

Status

Price

  • 2026-06-01

    Active

    $158,900

Documents

Documents Source: Doorify MLS IDX Feed

  • A single-story brick house with a gray roof sits among tall trees on a spacious, shaded yard at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension in Henderson. The home features a small covered front porch and several windows.
  • Empty living room with light blue walls, two windows with white valances, hardwood floor, a white front door, and a glass storm door. Sunlight streams in and white curtains hang by one window.
  • A mostly empty living room with light blue walls, white trim, hardwood floors, a window with a valance, a white front door, and an open doorway leading to a wood-paneled kitchen.
  • Empty room with light blue walls, hardwood floor, a wooden door, and a white fireplace with a red-tiled hearth. An open doorway reveals part of a bathroom in the background.

Nearby Listings

Statuses
Date Range
Price

1820 S Garnett Street Extension

$158,900

1435

Not in a Subdivision

$111

3

1959

0.31

Listed on
Jun 1st 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

$169,900

1398

Not in a Subdivision

$122

3

1960

0.29

Sold on
Jul 14th 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

$181,000

1811

Not in a Subdivision

$100

3

1964

0.3

Sold on
Jun 17th 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

222 Willowood Drive

$214,900

2184

Not in a Subdivision

$98

4

1930

0.55

Listed on
Feb 28th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

2064 Oxford Road

$309,000

2733

Not in a Subdivision

$113

4

1938

0.36

Listed on
Apr 1st 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

307 Yowland Road

$279,998

2230

Not in a Subdivision

$126

3

1963

0.42

Listed on
May 21st 2025

Doorify IDX Logo

1820 S Garnett Street Extension

$158,900

Doorify IDX Logo

$169,900

Doorify IDX Logo

$181,000

Doorify IDX Logo

222 Willowood Drive

$214,900

Doorify IDX Logo

2064 Oxford Road

$309,000

Doorify IDX Logo

307 Yowland Road

$279,998

Doorify IDX Logo
Listings Nearby to Listing
13 nearby listings found

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

Compared to Similar Homes that Recently Sold….

1820 S Garnett Street Extension has a Price per Square Foot of $111.

Here’s how that compares to the surrounding area:

17% below the Henderson Township median ($133)

17% below the City of Henderson median ($133)

16% below the Vance County median ($132)

  • A small single-story white house with a dark roof, black shutters, and a covered front porch sits at 431 Waddill Street in Henderson. Trimmed bushes and a green lawn frame the concrete walkway leading to the front door, with trees in the background.
    431 Waddill Street, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $157,500
    • $140 Price per Sqft
    • 1,127 Sqft
    • 0.21 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-08-11
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $1,400 less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (308 sq ft smaller)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($29 higher per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⚖️ (Similar vintage feel)

    The home on Waddill Street is significantly smaller and only offers two bedrooms, yet it sold for nearly the same total price as the home for sale. This highlights the value you are getting in square footage and bedroom count at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension. While this sold listing has a very clean and charming curb appeal, the extra room and larger footprint of the home for sale provide much better long-term utility for a similar investment.

    🟡 The home for sale gives you significantly more house for your money compared to this smaller two-bedroom sale.

  • A white single-story house with black shutters and a ramp leading to the front porch sits on a sloped lawn at 425 Rollins Avenue in Henderson. A driveway leads to a garage under the right side. The sky is partly cloudy.
    425 Rollins Avenue, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $80,000
    • $48 Price per Sqft
    • 1,654 Sqft
    • 0.34 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-12-17
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $78,900 less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬆️ (219 sq ft larger)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬇️ ($63 lower per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⬇️ (Major fixer upper)

    This property on Rollins Avenue represents the ‘fixer-upper’ floor of the local market, selling for a much lower price because it requires a total renovation. In contrast, 1820 S Garnett Street Extension is in much better physical condition and appears livable while you make your desired improvements. It sits comfortably in the market between the total project houses like this one and the fully renovated listings in the area.

    🟡 1820 S Garnett Street Extension is a much safer bet for a buyer who wants a home they can move into while slowly updating, rather than a full-scale renovation project.

  • A single-story brick house with white siding at 1809 S Garnett Extension in Henderson features a front porch, blue shutters, a car parked in the covered carport, a grassy yard surrounded by trees, and a chimney on the right side.
    1809 S Garnett Street Extension, Henderson, NC 27536
    • Price: $169,900
    • $122 Price per Sqft
    • 1,398 Sqft
    • 0.29 Acres
    • Sold on 2025-07-14
    Full Listing

    • Price: ⬆️ (Sold for $11k more)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (37 sq ft smaller)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($11 higher per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⬆️ (More updated finishes)

    This sold listing is a great benchmark because it is a similar brick ranch style located very close by. While it sold for a higher price, it features a more polished interior with painted kitchen cabinets and a refreshed bathroom vanity. The home for sale at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension offers slightly more living space for a lower entry price, which is a fair trade-off for the cosmetic updates it currently needs.

    🟡 If you are looking for a bit more space and don’t mind doing some painting, 1820 S Garnett Street Extension is a solid alternative to this more finished property.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the “why” behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

20 Minute Strategy Call-1 – Schedule a meeting

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.

A single-story brick house with a gray roof sits among tall trees on a spacious, shaded yard at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension in Henderson. The home features a small covered front porch and several windows.

1820 S Garnett Street Extension
Henderson, NC 27536

1820 S Garnett Street Extension
Henderson, NC 27536

$158,900

$158,900

Not in a Subdivision – Henderson Township – Vance County

A single-story brick house with a gray roof sits among tall trees on a spacious, shaded yard at 1820 S Garnett Street Extension in Henderson. The home features a small covered front porch and several windows.

1820 S Garnett Street Ext

Henderson

3 br

1435 sqft

$158,900

TWP Henderson

CTY Vance

SUB Not in a Subdivision

Share to...
LinkedInRedditThreadsPinterestBlueskyNextdoorChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AI