This is the most telling comparison because it was built by the same award-winning builder, Oak & Stone, and features the exact same high-end luxury finishes seen in the photos for 1219 Red Cedar Court. Both homes offer that desirable ranch-style layout with an upstairs bonus suite and identical gourmet kitchen packages. Despite being almost the same size and built to the same quality standard, this sold listing changed hands for $300,000 less than the current asking price for the home for sale.

This property across the street serves as a solid baseline for what buyers have recently paid for new construction in Cedar Knolls. 1219 Red Cedar Court is a much larger home with a more expansive custom layout and a third garage bay, which certainly justifies a higher total price. However, even when accounting for the extra square footage, the home for sale is asking for a significant premium per square foot compared to what was achieved here.

This home sold just down the street and offers a very similar new-construction profile with a three-car garage and custom details. While 1219 Red Cedar Court is larger and features slightly more elevated interior accents like the 14-foot ceilings, the price jump of $375,000 is quite steep for the additional space provided. Looking at the exterior, both properties offer that modern farmhouse aesthetic with high-end stone and siding work, but this sold listing suggests a much lower price point for the neighborhood.