Second Story Realty Logo

1186 Old Still Way
Wake Forest, NC 27587

$749,900

The Preserve at Smith Creek – Brassfield Township – Granville County

1186 Old Still Way
Wake Forest, NC 27587

$749,900

Save

Single Family

Active

The Preserve at Smith Creek

Brassfield Township

Granville County

  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 3.5
  • Square Feet: 3124
  • Acres: 1.42
  • Year Built: 2018

Single Family

Active

The Preserve at Smith Creek

Brassfield Township

Granville County

  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 3.5
  • Square Feet: 3124
  • Acres: 1.42
  • Year Built: 2018

4
Bed

3.5
Bath

3124
sqft

1.42
acres

  • 🪵 Hardwood Floors

  • ✨ Tall Vaulted Ceilings

  • 🛏️ Main-Level Primary Suite

  • 🛁 Soaking Tub

  • 🌿 Large Screened Porch

  • 🏊 Community Swimming Pool

Welcome to 1186 Old Still Way in the highly desirable Preserve at Smith Creek, where spacious living, privacy, and a great floor plan come together in a home designed to be enjoyed both inside and out. With 4 bedrooms, 3½ bathrooms, a main-level primary suite, and a private fenced backyard backing to a wooded area, this home offers the space you want with a setting that’s increasingly hard to find.

Step inside to find hardwood floors throughout the first floor and an open, airy design highlighted by tall vaulted ceilings in the family room and kitchen. The soaring ceilings and abundant natural light give the heart of the home an impressive sense of space while keeping the kitchen and living areas connected—equally well suited for entertaining a crowd or enjoying a quiet night at home.

The main-level primary suite is positioned to take full advantage of the peaceful backyard and wooded views beyond. The spacious bedroom is complemented by a large walk-in closet and a well-appointed primary bath featuring dual vanities, a soaking tub, and an oversized walk-in shower. It’s a comfortable retreat with the added bonus of never having to negotiate the stairs at the end of a long day.

Outdoor living is one of this home’s standout features. A large screened porch with a vaulted ceiling provides a wonderful place for morning coffee, evening dinners, or simply enjoying the outdoors without sharing your space with every mosquito in Wake County. Just beyond, the large elevated deck overlooks the fenced backyard and wooded area, creating an ideal setting for grilling, entertaining, or unwinding at the end of the day. The trees beyond the backyard provide a beautiful natural backdrop and an added sense of privacy.

And if you’re wondering where everything goes, this house has an answer. Walk-in attic space, crawl-space storage, a tall two-car garage, plus additional space beneath the deck and screened porch provide plenty of room for tools, outdoor gear, holiday decorations, hobbies, and all those things you absolutely plan to use again someday.

The Preserve at Smith Creek adds even more to enjoy without leaving the neighborhood. Community amenities include a swimming pool, playground, and sports field, while the neighborhood streets provide a great setting for morning walks, evening strolls, or getting in a run close to home.

With four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, generous storage, impressive vaulted living spaces, a main-floor primary suite, multiple outdoor living areas, and a private wooded backdrop, 1186 Old Still Way delivers a rare combination of space, comfort, and privacy in an established Wake Forest community. Come see why this one feels just as good outside as it does in.

Welcome to 1186 Old Still Way in the highly desirable Preserve at Smith Creek, where spacious living, privacy, and a great floor plan come together in a home designed to be enjoyed both inside and out. With 4 bedrooms, 3½ bathrooms, a main-level primary suite, and a private fenced backyard backing to a wooded area, this home offers the space you want with a setting that’s increasingly hard to find. Step inside to find hardwood floors throughout the first floor and an open, airy design highlighted by tall vaulted ceilings in the family room and kitchen. The soaring ceilings and abundant natural light give the heart of the home an impressive sense of space while keeping the kitchen and living areas connected—equally well suited for entertaining a crowd or enjoying a quiet night at home. The main-level primary suite is positioned to take full advantage of the peaceful backyard and wooded views beyond. The spacious bedroom is complemented by a large walk-in closet and a well-appointed primary bath featuring dual vanities, a soaking tub, and an oversized walk-in shower. It’s a comfortable retreat with the added bonus of never having to negotiate the stairs at the end of a long day. Outdoor living is one of this home’s standout features. A large screened porch with a vaulted ceiling provides a wonderful place for morning coffee, evening dinners, or simply enjoying the outdoors without sharing your space with every mosquito in Wake County. Just beyond, the large elevated deck overlooks the fenced backyard and wooded area, creating an ideal setting for grilling, entertaining, or unwinding at the end of the day. The trees beyond the backyard provide a beautiful natural backdrop and an added sense of privacy. And if you’re wondering where everything goes, this house has an answer. Walk-in attic space, crawl-space storage, a tall two-car garage, plus additional space beneath the deck and screened porch provide plenty of room for tools, outdoor gear, holiday decorations, hobbies, and all those things you absolutely plan to use again someday. The Preserve at Smith Creek adds even more to enjoy without leaving the neighborhood. Community amenities include a swimming pool, playground, and sports field, while the neighborhood streets provide a great setting for morning walks, evening strolls, or getting in a run close to home. With four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, generous storage, impressive vaulted living spaces, a main-floor primary suite, multiple outdoor living areas, and a private wooded backdrop, 1186 Old Still Way delivers a rare combination of space, comfort, and privacy in an established Wake Forest community. Come see why this one feels just as good outside as it does in.

Maps

Listing History

Date

Status

Price

  • 2026-08-18

    Active

    $772,500

  • 2026-08-26

    Price Decrease

    $749,900

Documents

Log in to your account to view 10 more available documents.

Documents Source: Doorify MLS IDX Feed

Nearby Listings

Statuses
Date Range
Price

1186 Old Still Way

$749,900

3,124

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$240

4

2018

1.42

Listed on
Aug 18th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

1185 Old Still Way

$750,000

3,004

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$250

3

2018

0

Sold on
Jun 18th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

3584 Creekstone Way

$594,500

2,769

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$215

4

2007

0.94

Sold on
Aug 21st 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

3587 Garner Terrace Way

$809,500

3,219

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$251

4

2015

1.46

Sold on
Jun 18th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

1202 New Grissom Way

$775,000

3,722

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$208

4

2013

1

Sold on
May 22nd 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

3581 Boulder Court

$650,000

3,247

The Preserve at Smith Creek

$200

4

2007

1.46

Sold on
Aug 20th 2026

Doorify IDX Logo

1186 Old Still Way

$749,900

Doorify IDX Logo

1185 Old Still Way

$750,000

Doorify IDX Logo

3584 Creekstone Way

$594,500

Doorify IDX Logo

3587 Garner Terrace Way

$809,500

Doorify IDX Logo

1202 New Grissom Way

$775,000

Doorify IDX Logo

3581 Boulder Court

$650,000

Doorify IDX Logo
Listings Nearby to Listing
16 nearby listings found

Examining another house that is similar, nearby, and recently sold can help determine if the price of this home for sale is priced appropriately.

Compared to Similar Homes that Recently Sold….

1186 Old Still Way has a Price per Square Foot of $240.

Here’s how that compares to the surrounding area:

6% above the Brassfield Township median ($228.50)

18% above the City of Wake Forest median ($205.50)

22% above the Granville County median ($199.50)

  • Charming two-story house at 3587 Garner Terrace Way, Wake Forest, with stone and blue siding, gabled roof, and multiple windows, nestled among tall pine trees and landscaped lawn with shrubs and mulch under a clear blue sky.
    3587 Garner Terrace Way, Wake Forest, NC 27587
    • Price: $809,500
    • $251 Price per Sqft
    • 3 Sqft
    • 1.46 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-06-18
    • Price: ⬆️ (Sold for $37k more)

    • Sq Ft: ⬆️ (38 sq ft larger)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($8 higher per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⬆️ (Slightly higher-end stone and trim)

    This property on Garner Terrace Way features a bit more heavy stone work on the exterior and luxury interior details like coffered ceilings. However, the home for sale at 1186 Old Still Way is priced significantly lower per square foot while offering a nearly identical amount of living space. You are getting the same footprint and a newer build date for a much more approachable price point.

    🟢 If you prefer a modern, airy aesthetic over heavy traditional accents, the home for sale represents a much better value.

  • 1202 New Grissom Way, Wake Forest, NC 27587
    • Price: $775,000
    • $208 Price per Sqft
    • 3 Sqft
    • 1 Acres
    • Sold on 2026-05-22
    • Price: ⬆️ (Sold for $2.5k more)

    • Sq Ft: ⬆️ (541 sq ft larger)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬇️ ($35 lower per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⬇️ (Visibly dated cabinetry and finishes)

    This home on New Grissom Way offers a lot more square footage and a finished basement for roughly the same price as the home for sale. However, a look at the photos reveals why: the interior features dated honey-oak cabinetry and older granite styles that lack the modern feel of 1186 Old Still Way. You are essentially choosing between more ‘raw’ space here or a move-in-ready, modern aesthetic at the home for sale.

    🟡 The home for sale appears fairly priced as a trade-off for buyers who prioritize modern style and a newer build over maximum square footage.

  • A two-story house with gray siding and white trim, a front porch with chairs, and surrounded by tall trees and a wooded yard. An American flag hangs near the porch, and a curved driveway leads to the home.
    1185 Old Still Way, Wake Forest, NC 27587
    • Price: $750,000
    • $250 Price per Sqft
    • 3 Sqft
    • Acres
    • Sold on 2026-06-18
    • Price: ⬇️ (Sold for $22.5k less)

    • Sq Ft: ⬇️ (177 sq ft smaller)

    • Cost/SqFt: ⬆️ ($7 higher per sq ft)

    • Condition: ⚖️ (Similar modern finishes)

    This sold listing is located right across the street and provides a perfect benchmark for the neighborhood. While it sold for a lower total price, it was a smaller home and actually cost more per square foot than the home for sale. Additionally, 1186 Old Still Way offers the convenience of a true one-story layout, which typically commands a premium over the two-story design found at this property.

    🟢 1186 Old Still Way offers more square footage and a more desirable layout for a lower price per foot than its immediate neighbor.

Take the Next Step…

5 Star Reviews


This level of clarity is how we work with every buyer and seller.

When you partner with Second Story Realty, you get a team that studies the market deeply, explains the “why” behind the numbers, and guides you with transparency at every step.

You can contact us to talk strategy, ask questions, or schedule a showing, we will help you take the next step with confidence.

Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. The listing broker shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Listings marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database.

Copyright 2025 Doorify MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Closed (sold) listings may have been listed and/or sold by a real estate firm other than the firm(s) featured on this website. Closed data is not available until the sale of the property is recorded in the MLS. Home sale data is not an appraisal, CMA, competitive or comparative market analysis, or home valuation of any property.

1186 Old Still Way
Wake Forest, NC 27587

1186 Old Still Way
Wake Forest, NC 27587

$749,900

$749,900

The Preserve at Smith Creek – Brassfield Township – Granville County

1186 Old Still Way

Wake Forest

4 br

3124 sqft

TWP Brassfield

CTY Granville

SUB The Preserve at Smith Creek

Share to...